BBC Review
The commercially 'unlucky' Liverpudlians show us why we should have listened the first...
Chris White2007
Whenever Shack are mentioned in print, invariably itâs not long before phrases like âcriminally underratedâ and âlost classicâ raise their clichĂ©d heads. Formed in 1988, the Liverpudlian four-piece have always been lavished with critical praise in inverse proportion to their meagre record sales, but perhaps the best way to summarise their career to date is âvery unluckyâ.
After an unremarkable first album, songwriter Michael Head and his band knew they had a potential hit on their hands with 1991âs Waterpistol. Falling somewhere between the classic Merseybeat of the Las and the fluid, Byrds-influenced melodies of the Stone Rosesâ eponymous debut, it seemed perfectly placed to catapult Shack to stardom. But a series of disastrous events, including a studio fire that destroyed the master tapes, meant Waterpistol did not see the light of day until 1995, by which time the music scene had moved on. After a four-year split, 1999âs HMS Fable emerged boasting a host of Oasis-like big choruses, but they jumped on the Britpop bandwagon just as it was grinding to a halt and the charts remained untroubled.
Unperturbed, Head and his sidekicks have continued to release great music ever since. Time Machine is a fine retrospective of their significant talent, featuring some of the best tracks from their four albums from Waterpistol onwards as well as several rare and previously unreleased songs.
The highlights are many, but the delicious yearning harmonies of âUndecidedâ and âNeighboursâ are probably the pick of Shackâs earlier work, while their evolution towards a more textured, orchestrated sound on 2003âs Hereâs Tom With The Weather is emphatically captured on the epic âMeant To Beâ, which employs scintillating mariachi brass and strings sections that would not be out of place on Loveâs timeless masterpiece Forever Changes.
Although new tracks âHoliday Abroadâ and âWandaâ are rather disappointing, the hitherto obscure âAlâs Vacationâ stands out as one of their best compositions, a quirkily tuneful little jaunt bringing to mind the lazy psychedelic folk of Pink Floydâs oft-overlooked post-Barrett, pre-Dark Side Of The Moon albums.
If you like Shack, you may already own much of whatâs here and decide you donât need this collection. But if youâre an admirer of intelligent, imaginatively arranged guitar pop thatâs yet to discover their charms, then Time Machine is quite simply an essential purchase.

